College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -
Staff Editorial

It is almost impossible to go anywhere and not be bombarded by Twilight. It’s an infection sweeping the nation and an international phenomenon that spawned the cult of twi-hards.

Stephenie Meyer, author of the Twilight series of books, is slowly but surely taking over the world. While Meyer tries to dazzle the reader with images of sparkly heroes, the heroine of her quartet of top-selling novels is a shallow, insecure, clumsy, whiney pushover. This is the girl that millions of young ladies around the world now aspire to be like.

Twilight is teaching young women that, to be happy, you need a man to control your every action, a man who clearly has issues with jealousy and a woman’s independence.

According to the National Center for Domestic Violence, overly controlling jealousy is one of the indicators of domestic violence. Yet Meyer makes it seem all right that Edward the vampire sneaks into Bella’s bedroom most nights and “watches her sleep” or tries to kill himself because they are not together.

It completely does away with the ideals of equality and feminism that so many have fought for. Bella is more than happy to let Edward, her father, Jacob, the vampire high council and Edward’s family all run her life and tell her what to do and when to do it in the name of protecting her and the world. Then, when left alone, all she can do about the situation is fall into a deep and debilitating depression that causes her to act out in impulsive, dangerous and life-threatening ways...

" />

Twilight series promotes anti-feminism

Published: Thursday, March 4, 2010

Updated: Thursday, March 4, 2010

Staff Editorial

It is almost impossible to go anywhere and not be bombarded by Twilight. It’s an infection sweeping the nation and an international phenomenon that spawned the cult of twi-hards.

Stephenie Meyer, author of the Twilight series of books, is slowly but surely taking over the world. While Meyer tries to dazzle the reader with images of sparkly heroes, the heroine of her quartet of top-selling novels is a shallow, insecure, clumsy, whiney pushover. This is the girl that millions of young ladies around the world now aspire to be like.

Twilight is teaching young women that, to be happy, you need a man to control your every action, a man who clearly has issues with jealousy and a woman’s independence.

According to the National Center for Domestic Violence, overly controlling jealousy is one of the indicators of domestic violence. Yet Meyer makes it seem all right that Edward the vampire sneaks into Bella’s bedroom most nights and “watches her sleep” or tries to kill himself because they are not together.

It completely does away with the ideals of equality and feminism that so many have fought for. Bella is more than happy to let Edward, her father, Jacob, the vampire high council and Edward’s family all run her life and tell her what to do and when to do it in the name of protecting her and the world. Then, when left alone, all she can do about the situation is fall into a deep and debilitating depression that causes her to act out in impulsive, dangerous and life-threatening ways.

Bella wants only one thing that goes against everyone else. She wants her completely not-gay, sparkly, 104-year-old boyfriend to kill her while she still is young and turn her into a vampire so they can be together forever. She forsakes her own independence, her family and a chance for a college education, all in the name of so-called love. She is incapable of being her own person; her character is molded by those around her.

Seriously, that is what this entire series is about. It is a miracle that it managed to sell one copy, let alone 85 million worldwide and in 38 languages. Worst of all, the final book in the series has Bella’s wish coming true and she and Edward procreating a hybrid human-vampire baby who already is in love with its mother’s former love interest. How screwed up is the entire Twilight universe that its followers want to live the same life as Bella?

Young women need positive, assertive role models who can, and will, stand up for themselves whether or not they find love. In the end, women need to be able to stand up for themselves. They need to set good examples for their daughters of the type of women they should grow up to be.

Bella Swan is none of those things. Edward Cullen is not Prince Charming. He is a PhotoShopped collage of everything women find attractive put in a sparkly, obsessive package. In reality, that is not what women need; it’s what they think they want. But like in all situations, the way something is imagined is way better than what it really is. Let’s be honest: Who really wants a cold, super-old guy constantly telling you what to do?

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

5 comments

Sarai
Wed Mar 31 2010 14:08
I totally disagree. Bella does not let Edward or anybody else control her. She makes her own decisions and actions. Romero killed himeself when he thought Juliet died, so how come you did not mentioned this too. Just because you did not like the book, you are making up stuff that is not even there. How is Bella's and Edward's relationship abusive? He wants want is best for her. Bella is stubborn and wants to be with Edward forever. She made up her mind, Edward did not make it up for her.
Anonymous
Sat Mar 13 2010 17:08
I think a lot of people are taking Twilight WAY to seriously.

Really.

No one that reads Twilight is going to go out and find an abusive boyfriend so they have have a relationship like Bella and Edward have. People who fall into abusive relationships are going to fall into abusive relationships no matter what they read. A book simply will not change someone's gut feelings and reactions in those types of situations.

Is Bella's character boring and wishy-washy and flat and all of that good stuff? Sure she is. But she's not an advocate for abusive relationships.

You also have to consider the way Edward acts towards Bella in a different way that you would a normal human boy, simply because of the fact that Edward is not human. Edward is a vampire. Is it creepy that he watches her sleep? No, he just doesn't sleep. Is it weird that he doesn't want her hanging out with Jacob? No, the two are mortal enemies. The danger of what the characters go through make them act they way they do, not the real-life, every day events that happen in.... REAL LIFE.

Also, don't know if you actually read the books, but Edward didn't try to kill himself because they weren't together in the second book. He tried to kill himself because he thought Bella was dead.

....Hmmm, sounds a bit like Romeo and Juliet, doesn't it? What, should that story be banned as well, due to the unhealthy obsessive love affair between the two that BROUGHT THEM TO THEIR DEATHS? ...Twilight actually seems tame to that outcome.

Yeah, it's freaking annoying that Bella trips all the time and Edwards reaction is always "LolGiggleBellaYouClutz." Believe me, the characters aren't perfect.

Listen, I'm not saying the books are awesome, but this article is claiming a little too much of something that simply isn't there. You are overreacting, kind of like "Video games make kids shoot their classmates!" If you truly believe that bit of nonsense, I'm certainly not going to change your mind about the Twilight series. However, if you agree that Video games actually do not sway children to commit horrible crimes, and that a child is going to commit one whether or not they play violent video games, isn't it the same with Twilight?

Girls are not going to take up abusive relationships simply because Bella is dating Edward.

Jaz
Thu Mar 4 2010 09:42
Gahh. I totally agree with you.
Christine
Thu Mar 4 2010 07:10
thank goodness...finally someone is writing about this! when i was growing up, i read about girls who were independent and comfortable with themselves...not passive, reactive extentions of men. i certainly did not recommend twilight to my cousin - i want her to want to be buffy, not edward's girlfriend!
N. Stillman
Wed Mar 3 2010 22:09
Absolutely agree. Bella is one of the most pathetic female protagonists ever to walk a page. I am so disheartened whenever I see one of the Twilight books clutched in the hands of a tween or a teen (or for that matter, an adult woman). I suggest the excellent Young Adult author, Tamora Pierce and her Song of the Lioness Quartet - beginning with Alanna: The First Adventure, for an example of a female protagonist who is strong, stubborn, uncompromising, capable and dependent on no man (no worries, there is plenty of action and romance).






log out